• Skip to content
  • Skip to footer
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to navigation
  • Skip to footer
University of Central Arkansas Logo

Arkansas Center for Research in Economics

Menu
  • UCA Home
  • Admissions
  • Academics
  • Campus Life
  • Athletics
  • Connect
  • About UCA
  • A to Z
  • Home
  • Our People
  • Research Areas
    • K-12 Education
    • Labor Market Regulation
    • Property Rights
    • Targeted Incentives
    • Taxes and Spending
    • Transparency
  • Student Programs
    • Undergraduate Research Fellows
    • Reading Group
  • Events
    • Speaker Series
    • Colloquia
  • Blog
  • K-12 Resources
    • Economics Nobel Prize Lecture Series
  • Contact Us
  • Annual Reports & Media

Bundrick Questions Benefits of Economic Development Incentives

By Caleb Taylor

Are economic development incentives a cost or benefit to Arkansas? 

ACRE Affiliated Researcher and UCA Lecturer I of Economics Jacob Bundrick was quoted in an article in the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette titled “Tax incentives audit cites impact on state; critics doubt programs key to luring firms,” published on December 14. 

The article focuses on an annual cost-benefit study of economic development incentives by Arkansas Legislative Audit.

The study found “TaxBack, Advantage Arkansas, Create Rebate and Invest Arkansas (incentive) programs have a net positive cost effectiveness, while In-House Research and Development-Targeted Business projects were negative cost effective.”

However, Bundrick disputed the study’s methodology of incentives being “analyzed under the assumption that, without the incentive, the corresponding economic activity would not have occurred.”

Bundrick said:

We see time and again that incentives are not the deciding factor in a company’s location/expansion decision, but merely serve as a reward for doing as they intended. In these cases, incentives are a cost to taxpayers and provide no benefit. Put more simply, if the assumptions used in the analysis are invalid, how can we trust the results? We’re making real decisions with real taxpayer money using analysis we know to be flawed.”

Bundrick was also interviewed by Paul Harrell on Conduit News on December 18 about the Arkansas Legislative Audit study.

Bundrick and UCA Assistant Professor of Economics Dr. Weici Yuan published a paper recently on a similar topic titled “Do Targeted Business Subsidies Improve Income and Reduce Poverty? A Synthetic Control Approach,” published in Economic Development Quarterly on September 20, 2019. 

Bundrick and Yuan use evidence from Arkansas’s Quick Action Closing Fund (QACF) to analyze how effective deal-closing funds are at increasing incomes and decreasing poverty at the county level. Their results indicate that the funds are ineffective at achieving these goals. 

For more of ACRE researchers’ work on targeted economic development incentives, go here.

Bundrick’s latest publication, “Government Accountability – 5 Fixes for Arkansas’s Quick Action Closing Fund” is a policy review highlighting five ways Arkansas officials could improve the Quick Action Closing Fund.

For a summary of the costs of Arkansas’s Quick Action Closing Fund, go here.

Posted in: Targeted Incentives on January 27, 2020 Tagged: Arkansas, government spending, incentives

Footer

Contact Us

University of Central Arkansas
College of Business
201 Donaghey Avenue
Conway, Arkansas 72035
E-mail: acre@uca.edu

Disclaimer

The views and opinions expressed herein are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the University of Central Arkansas nor are they endorsed by the University of Central Arkansas.

ACRE does not campaign for, promote, advocate, or support specific political parties or political candidates.

Follow Us!

Follow us on social media:

Facebook: Arkansas Center for Research in Economics ACRE
YouTube: Arkansas Center for Research in Economics
Twitter: @acre_uca

University of Central Arkansas · 201 Donaghey Ave., Conway, AR 72035 · (501) 450-5000
UCA is accredited by the Higher Learning Commission.
Report Web Accessibility Issue | Concerned About a Student? | Privacy
Copyright © 2026 · All Rights Reserved